Review of the Audiobook

The Case of the Damaged Detective

5-Minute Sherlock #1

The Audiobook Review Logo
The Case of the Damaged Detective

Loads of Sherlock Inspired Fun

Review by: The Audiobook ReviewThe Case of the Damaged Detective, written by Drew Hayes, is a fun new take on homages to Sherlock Holmes. There have been plenty in the past, and no doubt more in the future. This one sees a man, Sherman Holmes, who believes himself to be a descendent of the fictional detective.

He has no memory of who he used to be, but he's damn sure he's now the worlds greatest detective. The only survivor after exposure to an unknown chemical, Holmes' claim isn't without merit. Well... for five minutes per day at least. Other times, he's a lovable madman screaming his way through life like Daffy Duck on acid.

Agent 221... er, Joel Watson that is, is assigned as his bodyguard while Sherman is transported across the country. What starts out as an act of redemption for Watson, soon grows into something much more.

Both Holmes and Watson have the familiar traits you're looking for from these characters, with subtle twists and subversions to make them unique in their own right. The villains (Tom and Jenny) plus a host of others on their tails makes for an interesting story filled with plenty of humour and twists to keep it all moving forward at an easy clip.

Hayes has delivered a completely enjoyable addition to the wider world of Sherlockian fiction. Filled with loads of action, plot twists, humour and loads of heart, this is a series I'll be enjoying more of. I've already picked up the second book in the series!

Narration by Scott Aiello was fantastic, his voice of Sherman reminding me a lot of his voicework in Second Hand Curses. He's got a voice that's easy to listen to, and of course, being produced for Audible the quality was absolutely top-notch.

Narration Sample

TL;DR - Fun new Holmes and Watson adventures to get into! I'll be investigating more of these for sure.

The Case of the Damaged Detective

5-Minute Sherlock #1

Available From:


Comment on The Case of the Damaged Detective

Note: Your comments will appear immediately. However, we reserve the right to remove any comments that violate the rules outlined in our Terms of Service.

* Required information


Nothing to see here yet. Be the first!

Grab a Free Code
Richard: An Unlikely Love Story

LAF:  From the Eyes of Contentment 

Roberta Raves: Stories of Everyday Life Told with Humor, Insight and Compassion 

Set Good Boundaries 



We use cookies to improve your experience on our site. Read our Terms of Service to find out more. Continuing to use our site implies consent.
Agree to Cookies